What is a SOC 1 Type II Report?
A Service Organization Control (SOC) 1 Type II report is an attestation report issued by an independent auditor that evaluates a service organization's internal controls relevant to user entities' financial reporting.
Purpose and Scope
SOC 1 reports are designed for service organizations that provide services that impact their clients' (user entities') financial reporting. Common examples include:
- Payroll processing companies
- Claims processing services
- Data center operations affecting financial applications
- Third-party administrators for benefit plans
- Loan servicing organizations
- Transfer agents and registrars
Regulatory Framework
SOC 1 reports are prepared in accordance with:
- SSAE 18 (Statement on Standards for Attestation Engagements No. 18) in the United States
- ISAE 3402 (International Standard on Assurance Engagements 3402) internationally
- AT-C Section 320 for examination engagements
Type I vs Type II: Key Differences
| Aspect | Type I | Type II |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Design of controls | Design AND operating effectiveness |
| Time Period | Point in time (specific date) | Period of time (typically 6-12 months) |
| Testing | No testing of controls | Extensive testing over period |
| Evidence | Interviews, walkthroughs | Sample testing, observations, re-performance |
| Assurance Level | Limited assurance | Higher assurance (operational testing) |
Key Takeaway: Type II reports provide significantly more value to auditors because they include testing of whether controls actually operated as designed throughout the review period. Most financial statement auditors require Type II reports.
Components of a SOC 1 Report
A complete SOC 1 Type II report typically contains five sections:
Section I: Independent Service Auditor's Report
- Scope of the engagement
- Service auditor's responsibilities
- Opinion on control design and operating effectiveness
- Inherent limitations
Section II: Management's Assertion
- Management's statement regarding the fairness of the system description
- Assertion about controls being suitably designed
- Statement about operating effectiveness during the review period
Section III: System Description
- Overview of services provided
- Relevant aspects of control environment
- Risk assessment process
- Information and communication systems
- Monitoring activities
- Complementary user entity controls (CUECs)
Section IV: Control Objectives and Related Controls
- Detailed listing of control objectives
- Specific control activities designed to achieve each objective
- Tests of controls performed by the service auditor
- Results of testing
Section V: Other Information
- Trust Services Criteria (if applicable)
- Changes to the system during the review period
- Incidents or issues that occurred
- Other relevant information for user auditors
Understanding Control Objectives
Control objectives describe the intended result or purpose of controls within a system. They are directly linked to the risks that could prevent the service organization from achieving its operational goals related to user entities' financial reporting.
Common Control Objective Categories
- Logical Access: Controls ensuring only authorized users access systems and data
- Change Management: Controls over system and program changes
- Data Processing: Controls ensuring accurate and complete processing
- Backup and Recovery: Controls ensuring business continuity
- Monitoring: Controls for detecting and responding to issues
Best Practices for Efficient Review
1. Use Technology and Automation
Modern tools like SOC Review can reduce review time by 75% by automatically extracting control objectives, test procedures, results, and exceptions from PDF reports.
2. Focus on High-Risk Areas First
- Controls related to financial calculations
- Access controls to sensitive financial data
- Interfaces with user entity systems
- Areas with prior exceptions or deficiencies
3. Document Your Work Thoroughly
Maintain clear documentation of your review process, including how you evaluated the impact of exceptions and the rationale for your conclusions.
4. Communicate with Service Auditors
Don't hesitate to contact the service auditor for clarification on ambiguous control descriptions or testing results. They are required to respond to reasonable inquiries.
Automate Your SOC Review Process
SOC Review automatically extracts and organizes all the information covered in this guide, reducing review time from hours to minutes. Start your first review free.